Kathy - I personally have not yet tried the "soft" tear away, but something came to my mind when I read your post.
If it is manufactured to be 'soft' that might have an effect on the tearability of the stabilizer. I am wondering if you clipped or wet the remaining fibers to get rid of them. I am interested in your specific results because I have had tear away that did the same thing but it had other problems as well.
One thing about tear away is that it is meant to be easy to tear and therefore 'more loosely' compressed into the stabilizer. I have noticed in my cheaper tear away (which I let the grandkids draw on. . . ) there are thick and thin areas randomly.
Please do photograph the back side of the piece so we can see what is happening. We all can learn from your experience.
Pat, The Avid Embroiderer
If you are interested in selling your projects, you can determine your costs and profits quickly with my Spreadsheet.
If you want a lot of great information on working easier, faster and more confidently on your computer, check out my Tips and Tricks.
If you want to see my pashminas (that I successfully sell retail) check them out here. I also wholesale them.